Each of the main shots is one member of the Fellowship: the left orbit is Pippin, the right orbit Merry, the Shire target Sam, the right ramp Aragorn, the Ring Frodo, the inner orbit Gandalf, the left ramp Legolas, the Cave Gimli and the bumpers Boromir. Shoot each one to earn that member. With all nine earned, start the movie at the lit VUK, a kicker that fires the ball up from under the table; the surest way to reach it is the left orbit into Barad-dûr. If the machine has the optional Cave Troll opening switched on (from the factory it is off), you first earn five Cave Troll jackpots, and then the movie moves on to the Balrog.
Every movie multiball starts with three balls and ends when you are down to one. In Fellowship, hit the Balrog target and then either ramp to carry one member across the bridge. Do that for eight members, then hit the Balrog for Gandalf. That last Balrog shot wins the movie: five million and a Gift, and then Victory Laps begin. In Victory Laps the seven main shots each pay 500,000, going up 50,000 with every lap; a shot goes dark once you earn it, and shooting the Ring lights them all again. Victory Laps end when you are down to one ball. If you lose the movie part way across the bridge, the members you carried over stay carried for your next attempt.